Saturday, June 18, 2011

Arguments=Tyranny

Crooked Timber has a new troll:
Opposition to egalitarianism does not imply a hatred of liberty. There are plenty of libertarians who would consider themselves staunch defenders of liberty, but reject egalitarianism. In fact, many political theorists have noticed a trade off between liberty and equality. It is liberty and equality that have traditionally been at odds—with the right favoring liberty and the left favoring equality. Part of my point is that some of the methods the left uses to advance its vision are tyrannical. As for my aversion to someone seeking to change my mind, I provided a link to a respectable psychiatric study on Communist methods of “thought reform” for a reason. There is a difference between respectful discussion and an attempt at actual coercion. My objection is not to liberty, but to egalitarians who use unethical methods to force others to agree with them. Not because they are exercising liberty, but because they are tyrants.

7 comments:

The Modesto Kid said...

In other news...

ifthethunderdontgetya™³²®© said...

Crying Egal-libtardian.
~

vacuumslayer said...

Woo-HOO! Afternoon readin'!

Smut Clyde said...

Is new troll using Janusnode?

Big Bad Bald Bastard said...

Problem is that right wingers believe in liberty "for me, not thee".

tigris said...

Problem is that right wingers believe in liberty "for me, not thee".

Liberty for all would be too egalitarian.

Brando said...

There are plenty of libertarians who would consider themselves staunch defenders of liberty, but reject egalitarianism.

We call those people selfish assholes.